Middletown car accident claims, if not settled pre lawsuit are brought in the Court of Common Pleas of Butler, County, Ohio. That is if the damages you are seeking are in excess of $15,000.00 Otherwise your civil claim for car accident injuries can be brought in Middletown municpal court where Judge Mark Wall currently is the Judge. However the more serious auto accident injury lawsuits are brought in the Courthouse in downtown Hamilton. Ohio . You may get one of 7 judges.